A history lesson in the making

Australia is a tolerant country–especially if you fit in.

Submitted 2/11/2007 By Zoe Views 35908 Comments 16 Updated 29/11/2007



For African migrants in Australia, life just got a bit harder. As well as settling into a foreign country, African migrants have recently been targeted by the Immigration Minister for special mention, as they pose a ‘problem and a challenge’ in terms of integration.

In order to receive more refugees from Iraq and Burma, the annual nationality quotas have been changed. As the new 30 percent African quota (down from 70 percent) for 2007/08 has already been reached, no more African refugees will be allowed into Australia until at least July 2008. The doors are effectively shut to those escaping genocide in Darfur, civil war in Ethiopia, and those hoping to reunite with family already in Australia.

As abrupt as this may seem, Immigration Minister Kevin Andrews has managed to make things worse by suggesting the reason behind the cut was that ‘some groups don’t seem to be settling and adjusting into the Australian way of life’. He didn’t leave it at that. ‘Some groups’ he specified as Sudanese refugees, apparently involved in anything from gang violence to alcohol abuse.

These statements were based on ‘anecdotal evidence’ which Andrews refused to make public. Andrews’ statements have attracted publicity around the world, as newspapers from the UK, USA, Asia and Africa ponder his motivations. As a journalist from the Nigerian Tribune argued, ‘A refugee is running from danger and should not be asked what he thinks about integration.’ Kenya’s Business Daily reasoned, ‘We might call it tribalism in Kenya… We all know it is bare prejudice based on a manufactured difference.’

Andrews has taken a straightforward immigration matter and tried to turn it into a racial issue, just in time for the federal election. For the most part, the Australian public has failed to take the bait. . Media analyst Patrick Baume notes, ‘It certainly seems that the vast majority of people have no opinion at all or are simply not fussed about African immigrants.’

Australia has a history of official and unofficial racism. Italian migrants in the 1950s, Vietnamese migrants in the 1970s, and Chinese migrants in the 1990s are just a few groups who have faced similar racial discrimination upon arrival. Today, these groups are a celebrated part of Australia’s social fabric.

African migrant, Dr. Andre Renzaho, argues that former refugees ‘have become parents to lawyers, doctors and scientists that have made significant contributions to Australian life. African migrants will be equally successful, given time.’

Providing services to migrants, especially refugees, is admittedly a colossal undertaking. One refugee alone may require English language assistance, income support, vocational training, support to develop life skills, family counselling, health services and basic legal education, to assist their integration into society. The recent Budget allocated an additional $210 million to the $250 million already spent on migrant services. Yet these services often neglect rural areas and fail to engage young men in particular, making the results patchy at best.

For the next phase of Australia’s development as a multicultural society, services for refugees need to be improved and long-held attitudes need to change. To accept refugees based on their ability to integrate easily, instead of their humanitarian needs, is a mistake. Problems with integration should be acknowledged and dealt with, just as the successes of migrants should be celebrated.

In a country where racist immigration policies supposedly went out with the White Australia Policy in 1973, Andrews seems intent on continuing the tradition into the 21st century. But a little foresight and a good history lesson would help us all to realise that African refugees have a right to call Australia home.

How do I know this?

AAP 2007, ‘Africans accusing Andrews of racial slur’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 5 October, http://www.smh.com.au/news/National/Africans-accusing-Andrews-of-racial-slur/2007/10/05/1191091355822.html  

AAP 2007, ‘Andrews unbowed, Sudanese tensions brew’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 11 October, http://www.smh.com.au/news/NATIONAL/Andrews-unbowed-Sudanese-tensions-brew/2007/10/11/1191696047864.html  

Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs.2007, 'Australia’s Support for Humanitarian Entrants', Australian Government, http://www.dimia.gov.au/media/publications/visa-entry/_pdf/ashe.pdf  

Editorial 2007, ‘Australia and African Refugees’, Nigerian Tribune, 9 October, http://www.tribune.com.ng/09102007/edit.html  

Metherell, M 2007, ‘Where angels fear to tread’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 13 October, http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/where-angels-fear-to-tread/2007/10/12/1191696173839.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1  

Ogola, G 2007, ‘How Fear of the ‘Outsider’ Rules Elections’, Business Daily (Kenya), 15 October, http://allafrica.com/stories/200710160131.html  

Pearlman, J 2007, ‘Andrews, Howard deny racism’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 5 October, http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/andrews-howard-deny-racism/2007/10/04/1191091276214.html  

Renzaho, A 2007, ‘Slamming the door on Africa’, The Sydney Morning Herald, 9 October, http://www.smh.com.au/news/opinion/slamming-the-door-on-africa/2007/10/08/1191695819548.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1  

Ricketson, M 2007, ‘There’ll be no whistling up another Tampa’, The Age, 15 October, http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/therell-be-no-whistling-up-another-tampa/2007/10/14/1192300597622.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1  

Rout, M 2007, ‘Unis unite to slam ‘racist’ Andrews’, The Australian, 9 October, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22554203-12332,00.html  

The panel discusses African Immigration. 2007, television program, Insiders, ABC TV, 7 October, http://www.abc.net.au/news/video/2007/10/07/2052837.htm  

Tony Burke speaks to Insiders. 2007, television program, Insiders, ABC TV, 7 October, http://www.abc.net.au/insiders/content/2007/s2052835.htm  

Discuss Now

Post Comment 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |

RSS Comments
image

funnelweb 18-Nov-2007

Sheree- I apologise for what is implied in suggesting your views were anti-Australian. It was wrong of me, I was just frustrated by what appeared to be constant criticisms of this country and criticisms which I personally believed to be unwarranted, particularly as you identified that there is no system to mirror in any developed world country. So this immigration thread is really a global issue not a domestic one.

I have offered constructive solutions. My belief is that Australia has a duty to a reasonable intake of refugees and to provide true refugees with all luxuries afforded to Australians, including housing, education, health etc. They must be screened so that we are not allowing in "undesirables" such as those with criminal histories. Secondly, Australia must assist in helping to tackle the source of the problem, which i do not attribute to western intervention. 1/3 of Zimbabwe's population has fled as refugees to neighbouring countries and are persecuted and mistreated, many women forced into prostitution. In Sudan many are slaughtered. In Iraq they fled Saddam now they flee suicide bombings and civil unrest. In Somalia to flee Sharia and war. I think the western world has a duty to intervene rather than sit back and watch developing nations engage in genocide and civil uproar. The organisations I identified earlier should be supported. They provide ground support in getting food, clothing and medical supplies to those on the ground, and assist in lobbying Governments to find peaceful outcomes.

-----

image

Rach 16-Nov-2007

Funnelweb, you said: "Sheree since you are so anti-Australian". Please don't label or bully people like that. It's just not cool. Grow up. Secondly, there is no ONE nation that any other country can be modeled off, but aspects. And in this case, to do with immigration and refugees, etc, we could draw on some systems (like, Canada I think? Don't quote me) where refugees are placed in small villages to live in until their forms are processed. And people are never kept processed in longer than 30 days. Here, we keep people in cages and take years to process.
While this may be more of a discussion about refugees, the question should not be "whose fault it is, and who needs to clean it up" - but the fact that we are all human beings, what are we ethically and morally questioning ourselves to do? Yes, there is endless debate about this. But instead of saying "it's their fault" lets say "well, damn, this problem exists. What can we do about it?"
Global warming, extinction, deforestation, refugees, racism, war are all global issues which don't begin anywhere, or belong to anyone (in most cases). Sure, there are major contributors, but, in the end, everyone must deal with the burden of these consequences of depleted and abused resources and lives.
Yeah, personally, i'm idealist to think that we can overlook 'me vs them' and just deal with the problem, but, hey, that's me. I'll admit that.

So what are YOUR ideas for SOLVING this problem?
/rant.

-----

image

Sheree 16-Nov-2007

Anti-Australian?

Are you sure you don't mean 'un-australian'?

I believe that is the catchphrase used ad-nauseum that bears absolutely no significance in the context of political discussions.

I won't answer your question in the same vein that I am not idealistic enough to believe that a utopian system is in place anywhere in the world.

While you're coming up with some more challenges you might want to address some of the points already raised.

-----

image

funnelweb 16-Nov-2007

Sheree since you are so anti-Australian I re-ask the question I posed earlier, please name me one country whose system you would like us to emulate as a starting point and identify its qualities?



-----

image

Meli 14-Nov-2007

!

“…stats clearly show there were far more iraqi refugees fleeing saddam than fleeing from American occupation.”

What stats?

There were many refugees fleeing Iraq back then, there are more now.

“These numbers are staggering in a population estimated in the pre-invasion years at only 26 million. At a bare minimum, in other words, at least one out of every seven Iraqis has had to flee his or her home due to the violence and chaos set off by the Bush administration's invasion and occupation of Iraq.”

Source: http://www.alternet.org/waroniraq/50946/

“The UN estimates that over 4 million Iraqis have been displaced by violence in their country, the vast majority of which have fled since 2003.”

Source: http://www.refugeesinternational.org/content/artic...

Makes sense, considering ONE reason our gov. gave for accepting more refugees from Iraq (therefore cutting African numbers) is that the situation has worsened.

-----