Scientology: science fiction or gospel?

Can scientology claim to be a religion with any credibility?

Submitted 27/03/2008 By redbj Views 7802 Comments 13 Updated 21/04/2008


Photographer : markbult @ flickr

There has been much debate about whether Scientology should be considered an official religion.

One thing is for sure, Scientology is a worldwide phenomenon, with an estimated 10 million followers in 159 countries operating out of 6,000 specialised churches.

Scientology is legally seen as a legitimate religion in both Australia (where there are around 2000 believers) and in its country of origin, the United States. And considering it shares many similarities with the world’s traditional faiths—most obviously Christianity and Judaism—Scientology can lay strong claim to its status as a religion.

Like traditional faiths, Scientology requires believers to give financial donations; has a narrative central to its beliefs, and considers man a spiritual being— not simply flesh and blood. And according to Mark Oppenheimer from the Washington Post, Scientology, like most religions, becomes increasingly authoritarian and cult-like at the higher levels of the faith.

But whilst Scientology shares similarities with other faiths, it takes religious narrative to a whole new level—a level of science fiction fantasy that is way beyond belief.

The Scientology farce

‘Scientology’ literally translated means, ‘the study of truth’, but to any non-believer the foundations of Scientology are very hard to believe.

In a nutshell, Scientologists claim that tens of millions of years ago an alien named Xenu, from a distant planet unknown to man, rounded up 13.5 trillion beings from various planets in the galaxy and flew them to Earth.

These beings were then dumped into Earth’s volcanoes and vaporized with bombs. These bombs scattered the being’s evil spirits (or ‘body thetans’ in Scientology speak) across the globe and in turn the spirits attached themselves to human beings. Scientologists believe it’s these spirits that are responsible for all our weaknesses, including sin and illness.

Scientology proclaims that the only way that humans can rid themselves of the evil body thetans is through the teachings of their spiritual guru, L. Ron Hubbard. Once human beings have been enlightened by the teachings of Hubbard, we will then be able to create perfect human societies free from insanity, crime and war.

The cost of knowledge

In Scientology, knowledge is imparted to believers like goods are bought from a store.

“What’s special about this cult is the price believers are charged to take each step along the ‘Bridge to Total Freedom’. It's pay as you go. Pay per view of the secret texts” says Australian journalist David Marr.

Hubbard himself remarked in the 1940s (before he had fully developed Scientology) that ‘if a man really [wanted] to make a million dollars, the best way would be to start his own religion’.

Estimates of how much it costs to reach Scientology’s holy level of Operating Thetan (OT) range between $US100,000 and $US300,000. The church is structured so that followers pay greater and greater amounts of money for spiritual guidance depending on their position within the church and their level of theological knowledge.

This is a major reason why so many celebrities have been lured into the church’s clutches — most notably James Packer, Isaac Hayes, John Travolta and of course Hollywood action man, Tom Cruise who has become the perfectly chiselled poster boy of Scientology. Cruise has been a practicing Scientologist for 20 years and is currently the second most powerful member of the church, making him an ‘Operating Thetan 7’.

Janet Reitman, who embarked on a nine month investigation into Scientology in 2006 for Rolling Stone Magazine (US), discovered OTs to be regarded as ‘enlightened beings who are said to have total 'control' over themselves and their environment. OTs can allegedly move inanimate objects with their minds, leave their bodies at will and telepathically communicate with, and control the behaviour of, both animals and human beings.’

However, this is all part and parcel of Scientology’s fictional illusion. After all, who wouldn’t be interested in being able to move inanimate objects without physically touching them?

Edward Lottick, father of a 24 year-old Pennsylvanian man who committed suicide in 1991 after loosing everything to Scientology, believes the church prays upon the very human weaknesses its theology claims to free us from. ‘I believe it's a school for psychopaths. Their so-called therapies are manipulations. They take the best and brightest people and destroy them,’ Lottick stated.

By charging believers huge amounts of money for bad science fiction writing that masquerades as religious gospel, Scientology has developed a strong global following. But how it can be seen as a legitimate religion, is simply beyond me.

How do I know this?

Associated Press 2007, ‘Push to Charge Scientologists’, The Australian, 6 September

Behar, R 1991, ‘The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power’, Time Magazine, May, www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,972865,00.html  

Marr, D 2008, ‘Print and be Damned’, The Age, 19 January

Oppenheimer, M 2007, ‘Weird, Sure. A Cult, No’, The Washington Post, 5 August

Reitman, J 2006, ‘Inside Scientology: Unlocking the complex code of America's most mysterious religion’, Rolling Stone Magazine, February, www.rollingstone.com/politics/story/9363363/inside_scientology  

Religious Tolerance, www.religioustolerance.org/scientol.htm  

The Church of Scientology - Australia, www.scientology.org.au  

The Church of Scientology - International, www.scientology.org  

The Gawker, the Cruise Indoctrination Video Scientology Tried To Suppress, http://gawker.com/5002269/the-cruise-indoctrination-video-scientology-tried-to-suppress  

What is Scientology? www.whatisscientology.org

Discuss Now

Post Comment 1 | 2 | 3 |

RSS Comments
image

Zenna Baxter 23-Nov-2009

Thanks for posting this info about Scientology. I think it's really important that people critically analyse Scientology before they ever consider joining it.

From research I've done they have some very useful tools to help people get through their problems which is one of the reasons people get involved in the first place. They don't know everything they are getting into because that's against the rules of being a successful scientologist. It's only after years and thousands of dollars can someone reach OT III and learn about Xenu.

I really recommend going to www.xenutv.com it has a lot of videos and articles about Scientology and there are both ex members and current members filmed and interviewed. It's definitely worth a look for anyone interested.

-----

image

shelleyq 08-Apr-2008

I’m intrigued by the whole concept of Scientology; I had a look at some of these websites and it’s really incredible to me that this religion was created so recently and that anyone can create a religion at all! How did Mr. Hubbard think all this up and why are people willing to believe it. What gives a former science-fiction writer the authority to make up a religion?
I’ve read a little about Scientology before but haven’t come across anything about Scientologists’ belief in ‘evil body thetans’. How did Hubbard determine this?
Also, in a section of Christopher Reeve’s book, Nothing is Impossible, he describes his first encounter with the Scientology in the 1970s; I was astounded that even back then people were being charged thousands of dollars to obtain the secrets of Scientology. If these sums of money were being collected way back then and people like Tom Cruise are pouring $300,000 dollars into the religion today, where is all the money going?

P.S. If anyone is interested in getting a Scientologist’s perspective I recommend reading the article from Rolling Stone attributed below.

-----

image

CMatloub 04-Apr-2008

I couldn't agree more with this article! What I don't understand is how on earth Scientologists can believe such outlandish claims! Why doesn't summon just sit them down and show them scientific proof that they are wrong! For instance with Tom Cruise and postpartum depression there's medical evidence to back it up!

-----

image

Meli 03-Apr-2008

[“…but unfortunately Scientology has hurt many people’s lives and forced many people into bankruptcy and suicide.”]

That’s true. Do you know how common this is though?

[ “…what for me makes Scientology an illegitimate religion is the fact it is run like a commercial business rather than a religion.”]

I agree that it seems dodgy. But if followers know what they’re getting into (I’m assuming the majority do, but I could be wrong) then they aren’t being taken advantage of.

-----

image

*dani* 02-Apr-2008

I definetely agree with redbj. I think that it is important to question the validity of religions, just like we question the politicians who hand laws down to us and the leaders of our country. I think the comment redbj made about Scientology being run like a business is true. It is also important to remember that there are many religions across the world that ask for money in that way, and not to give it to charity but to create ridiculous Churches with plasmas and other luxuries. American Evangelists come to mind. Anyway, I thought the article was well-written and well researched.

-----